Achieving 500 victories is a truly monumental feat. Below is the updated list, through 2024, of those few coaches who have reached that plateau. Most of this data was provided by the NY Sportswriters Association. If you know of any deserving coaches we may have missed or corrections to any of their totals, please let us know.

Coach	School(s)	Wins
Jack Curran	Archbishop Molloy-CHSAA	972
Ron Naclerio	Cardozo-PSAL	961
Ed Petrie	East Hampton-11	754
Mike Rapone	Batavia Notre Dame-5	728
Chuck Granby	Jackson, Campus Magnet-PSAL	722
John Mathis	Bronx JFK-PSAL	673
Tim Leary	St. Francis Prep-CHSAA	646
Tom Blackford	Fayetteville-Manlius, Hamilton-3	643
Jack Halloran	Whitney Point-4	630
Rod Chando	Red Hook-9	626
Jeff Weiss	Lawrence-Woodmere-AIS	625
Bob Cimmino	Mount Vernon-1	623
Dudley Maxim	Trinity School-NYC	619
Jeff Anastasia	Olean-6	602
Bob Clark	Riverdale-NYC	599
Bill Merna	Hammond, Ogdensburg Free Academy-10	599
Sam Kalloch	Poughkeepsie-9	588
Tom Murray	Cardinal Hayes-NYC	582
Floyd Bank	Long Island City, Edison-PSAL	579
Buddy Wleklinski	Syracuse CBA-3	578
Larry Byrnes	Collegiate School-AIS	577
Lou Panzanaro	Peekskill-1	576
Pat Donnelly	East Syracuse-Minoa, Bishop Ludden-3	571
Mike Adey	Rome Catholic, New York Mills-3	567
Jim Gatto	St. John's Prep-NYC	562
Jerry Kaplan	James I. O'Neill-9	560
Lee Fisher	Davenport-4	553
Bob Oliva	Christ The King-CHSAA	549
George Mardigan	Watervliet-2	546
Ed Nietopski	Cardinal Mooney, Bishop Kearney-5	545
Mel Palano	Bishop Timon-St. Jude-MM	544
Harry Moskowitz	James Madison-NYC	541
Al Knapp	Brookfield, V-V-S-3	539
Jack Agostino	Amityville, Bay Shore, Amityville-11	530
John Volpe	Gorton, Sacred Heart-1	528
Jim Zullo	Shenendehowa-2, Broadalbin-Perth-2 and Indian Lake-7	528
Roger Rigby	Scio-5	527
Chris Cardon	Eastridge,Irondequoit-5	523
Dave Powers	Oswego-3	520
John Demas	William C. Bryant-NYC	519
George Khoury	Warrensburg-2	518
Walter Bachman	Valley Stream North-8, Jericho-8	518
Jim Burke	Prattsburgh-5	517
Ted Adams	Hempstead-8	517
Charlie Folsom	Harrisville-10	515
Paul Lyons	Albany-2	515
Bob McKenney	Jamesville-DeWitt and Bishop Grimes-3	514
Bob Hettler	Amherst-6	514
Mike Del Val	Woodlands, Alexander Hamilton, Rye-1	514
Tony Rafaniello	Monsignor Farrell, New Dorp, Moore-CHSAA	511